By Rick Christie
Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Updated: 7:49 a.m. Monday, Nov. 30, 2009
JUPITER — Friends and family of four victims of a tragic Thanksgiving Day shooting here are expected to memorialize two of them tonight.
Meanwhile, the manhunt continues for Paul Michael Merhige, who police allege, that on Thanksgiving night opened fire, killing his aunt, Raymonde Joseph, his twin sisters Carla Merhige and Lisa Knight, and 6-year-old Makayla Sitton. Two others attending the dinner also were shot.
Police said Sunday they hope a $10,000 reward will yield tips that lead them to Paul Michael Merhige. The U.S. Marshals Florida Regional Fugitive Task Force offered the reward for information leading to Merhige’s arrest. The Palm Beach County State Attorney’s Office has issued an arrest warrant for Merhige for four counts of first-degree murder and two counts of attempted first-degree murder.
Police are looking for Merhige, 35, in Florida and Michigan.
Merhige was last seen driving a blue 2007 Toyota Camry with the Florida license plate W42-7JT.
Authorities ask anyone with information about Merhige to contact Jupiter police at (561) 746-6201.
The heartbreaking account of how a mentally troubled relative broke bread with his estranged family and then systematically began killing them has provoked an outpouring of sympathy from strangers.
It has also garnered national attention. This morning, CBS’ Early Show interviewed Jim and Muriel Sitton — parents of little Makayla — at their home about the tragedy.
Channel 5 said many people are asking where to send flowers and cards to the Sittons. It directed them to the Sittons’ church, Calvary Chapel Palm City, 1633 SW 34th St., Palm City, Fla. 34990.
At 7:30 tonight at Our Lady of Lebanon Church in Miami, family and friends will gather for a memorial to the twin sisters.
Patrick Knight, Lisa’s husband, was also shot. He remains hospitalized but is expected to recover.
Family members of the victims told Jupiter police that Knight was pregnant, but a spokesman for the police said they had not independently confirmed that by Sunday. If they do, it would be up to the state attorney’s office whether to charge Merhige in the death of the unborn baby.
In 1973, Merhige’s aunt killed her husband, her two children and herself.
Suzanne Merhige, a cousin to the family, said on Sunday that words couldn’t begin to express the shock the family is going through.
“There is nothing evil in any of this family,” said Merhige, who lives in Daytona Beach. “These are good, sincere, people. They may have been suffering with Paul, but what I do know is that this is a very good family.”
In 1998 and 2006, Carla Merhige accused her brother Paul of domestic violence, although the cases were dropped.
Vanessa Archer, a co-worker and friend of Carla’s, said she never showed any signs that she felt she was in danger.
“God no,” Archer said. “She was a great person and a wonderful colleague. She gave so much to foster care children. It’s a huge loss for the community.”
In Jupiter, the Sittons returned to their home Sunday afternoon for the first time since the Thanksgiving shooting spree killed their daughter and three other relatives.
The Sittons hosted a Thanksgiving meal for 17 people at their house on Via Veracruz in Jupiter. At 10 p.m., police allege, Paul Michael Merhige opened fire.
The Sittons allowed a Channel 5 co-worker to film their daughter’s bedroom Sunday, and Jim Sitton told the station he had feared the emotions that he would face upon seeing it. Instead, with the ruffled bed neatly made and the dolls and toys straightened just so, the Bible marked where she had been reading, the room seemed to bring him peace.
“I was dreading coming in here,” he said. “But once I did, I just see all the evidence of her specialness and uniqueness.”
He held up the last photo ever taken of her, in a pretty Thanksgiving holiday frock. “She’s beautiful,” Sitton said.
Staff writers Jeff Ostrowski, Andrew Abramson and Stacey Singer contributed to this report.

Thanksgiving Sales Attract more Shoppers, Less Average Spending

Recent Comments